home page index of articles    
COTAC COTAC COTAC
Historic Scotland

TAN 11
Fire Protection Measures in Scottish Historic Buildings

With one important Scottish building currently being lost each month to the effects of fire, it can readily be seen that this is one of the single greatest threats to the fabric and contents of historic buildings in the country. Each year brings a steady toll of buildings destroyed or badly damaged. Authentic fabric lost to fire is irreplaceable: no matter how good subsequent restoration may be, the original has been lost forever. It follows that the conservation and protection of our historic buildings must involve giving them the best possible protection from fire. This is not to ignore the safety of occupants, which remains of paramount importance, rather to ensure that fire protection measures look beyond the immediate requirements of life safety to encompass the protection of the building fabric and contents as well.

Much can be done by good management to prevent fires from occurring in the first place. Beyond this, the installation of fire detection and protection systems may be required. There are many devices available, from simple smoke detectors to carefully engineered detection, alarm and suppression systems. However, in some instances, such technology demands a level of intervention in the fabric that is unacceptable in conservation terms. Measures taken to protect the fabric must not damage what they set out to protect. A balance needs to be established.

This document is concerned, firstly, with setting out measures to identify and eliminate risk from fire by effective management and, secondly with reviewing appropriate technologies, whilst examining the effect of their introduction into historic buildings. Fire protection measures may range from simple common sense to, in the most developed form, a fire engineering approach which seeks to bring a rational, analytical process to bear. At every level of its consideration a great deal of care is required in order to achieve a balanced outcome which makes the best use of available resources and is consistent with accepted conservation principles.

This Technical Advice note is the eleventh in an occasional series of notes on practical and technical issues, which can arise in safeguarding the nation’s heritage. It intends to give guidance on the principles involved in the effective protection of historic buildings from the effects of fire. It is not intended as a prescriptive document nor as definitive specifications for provisions on site. Although primarily aimed at offering advice and information of use to Historic Scotland staff, is intended to be of value to others who have to consider fire risk and protection measures for historic buildings.

Throughout the compilation of this publication Historic Scotland has been indebted to the support has received from all the members of the Discussion Forum.

INGVAL MAXWELL Director, TCRE